(no subject)
Jan. 2nd, 2010 08:02 pmSo, answer me this, the internet, and satisfy my curiosity:
Poll #2007 gift exchanges: to prompt or not to prompt?
Open to: All, detailed results viewable to: All, participants: 176
I have participated or am participating in fannish gift exchanges (for fic, vids, art, whatever)
yes![]()
![]()
163 (93.1%)
no, so I'm going to stop taking this poll now![]()
![]()
8 (4.6%)
no, but I will do this poll and give the answers I IMAGINE I'd give if I did![]()
![]()
4 (2.3%)
I have received an assignment or assignments with:
absolutely no voluntary prompt information whatsover![]()
![]()
60 (35.9%)
a bit of prompt information ("Millicent and the dryad, backstory!" "My favourite character is Sandra!")![]()
![]()
123 (73.7%)
a medium amount of prompt information (say a short paragraph or two)![]()
![]()
134 (80.2%)
a ton of prompt information (several long paragraphs)![]()
![]()
47 (28.1%)
On average, I have found the following MOST helpful (when RECEIVING an assignment):
absolutely no voluntary prompt information![]()
![]()
1 (0.6%)
a bit of prompt information![]()
![]()
17 (10.2%)
a medium amount of prompt information![]()
![]()
131 (78.4%)
a ton of prompt information![]()
![]()
18 (10.8%)
I have experienced the following conditions (when RECEIVING an assignment):
absolutely no voluntary prompt information, and it was helpful![]()
![]()
7 (4.2%)
a bit of prompt information, and it was helpful![]()
![]()
101 (60.5%)
a medium amount of prompt information, and it was helpful![]()
![]()
140 (83.8%)
a ton of prompt information, and it was helpful![]()
![]()
42 (25.1%)
absolutely no voluntary prompt information, and it was troublesome/frustrating![]()
![]()
72 (43.1%)
a bit of prompt information, and it was troublesome/frustrating![]()
![]()
63 (37.7%)
a medium amount of prompt information, and it was troublesome/frustrating![]()
![]()
19 (11.4%)
a ton of prompt information, and it was troublesome/frustrating![]()
![]()
31 (18.6%)
When WRITING a prompt for a stranger in an exchange-fest, I usually:
give no details (I can't come up with anything/find it difficult)![]()
![]()
1 (0.6%)
give no details (I choose not to)![]()
![]()
0 (0.0%)
give some details![]()
![]()
50 (29.9%)
give lots of details with a clear caveat that I'm not married to any of them![]()
![]()
104 (62.3%)
give lots of details (it's a gift for me, after all, and a vague prompt is nobody's friend)![]()
![]()
9 (5.4%)
give lots of details (the prompts tend to get away from me)![]()
![]()
3 (1.8%)
People who give absolutely no prompt information:
allow their gifter creative freedom![]()
![]()
10 (6.1%)
make me want to tear my hair out![]()
![]()
138 (83.6%)
are fine, I don't care![]()
![]()
17 (10.3%)
People who give a medium amount of prompt information
strike a nice balance![]()
![]()
134 (80.7%)
are often so wishy-washy that you might as well not have a prompt![]()
![]()
4 (2.4%)
are fine, I don't care![]()
![]()
28 (16.9%)
People who give lots and lots of prompt information
are specific about what they want, which helps me as a writer/vidder/artist![]()
![]()
70 (42.7%)
make me feel like I have no creative freedom![]()
![]()
41 (25.0%)
are fine, I don't care![]()
![]()
53 (32.3%)
I participate in gift-challenges primarily as a(n):
writer, and I love receiving detailled prompts![]()
![]()
136 (82.9%)
writer, and I love receiving prompts without any details![]()
![]()
14 (8.5%)
vidder, and I love receiving detailled prompts![]()
![]()
8 (4.9%)
vidder, and I love receiving prompts without any details![]()
![]()
3 (1.8%)
artist, and I love receiving detailled prompts![]()
![]()
15 (9.1%)
artist, and I love receiving prompts without any details![]()
![]()
8 (4.9%)
organizer, and have found that people prefer to receive detailled prompts![]()
![]()
8 (4.9%)
organizer, and have found that people prefer not to receive any details![]()
![]()
2 (1.2%)
your poll cannot contain my fannish identity, even though this question has checkboxes and not radio buttons![]()
![]()
15 (9.1%)
When writing gift-exchange prompts, I wish people would:
![[livejournal.com profile]](http://s.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)